What's new

What type of camera would you rather use?

There's always a "right tool for the job". Sometimes it could be a Leica S2, if you're in a studio. Do you want to take that S2 to a baseball diamond, hockey rink or a football or soccer field? Probably not.

Everything in cameras, regardless of brand, regardless of price, is a trade off. Sometimes, that price IS the trade off, sometimes, the camera is even over priced.

In a perfect world where all cameras were free, I'd want a nice blend of options for myself. Sure, I'd take an S2 with a hand full of primes. But at the same time, I'd also take a Nikon D4 with the zoom trinity as well. While I'm at it, may as well throw in an Olympus EM-1, complete with a bunch of lenses.

Again...right tool for the job. Granted, especially in the realm of 35mm sensors, the more expensive the camera, the more the camera itself does more well. Lets face it...since Canon has a camera for everything and Nikon has more holes than a block of Swiss cheese, I'll use them as a better example. Canon 1D X and 7D. The best Canon has to offer for full frame and APS-C, respectively. We have to be realistic here. Outside of sheer size, the 1D X out preforms the 7D in every way, but the 5D Mk 3 will do better than the 7D, so that takes us to the 5D Mk 3 vs the 1D X. This is where a nice trade off comes into play. Sure, the 1D X is the all round better performer, but sometimes, the size isn't desirable. If I had to choose between the two in a backpacking scenario, I'd opt for the 5D Mk 3, but if I were going to a game intent on making a living through my photos, I'd be all over the 1D X as it simply will do a better job. Granted, the 5D 3 is no slouch, but its frame rate is exactly 1/2 of the 1D X.

Likewise though, if I were backpacking and had to choose between the 5D 3 and an Olympus EM-1 system, you bet I'm going to take the Oly.

It all comes down to the right tool though. There's a place for nearly every class of camera, ranging from the most expensive to the camera to the one on your phone. There'll never be a "perfect" camera for any one body or lenses. That's why we have options.
 
Why don't we try and steer this back to something more fruitful, like a good ole' Ford vs. Chevy debate? Or maybe a Pepsi vs. Coke line of posts and replies. Or, oh,oh,oh, I got it, how about a good old fashioned Mac versus PC debate!!!
 
Could we do Pepsi vs Ford? Or Coke vs Mercedes?
 
Could we do Pepsi vs Ford? Or Coke vs Mercedes?

Shouldn't that be Pepsi vrs Mercedes and Coke vrs Ford - you know, since a lot of people who drive Ford's drink Pepsi and a lot of people who drive Mercedes snort coke? Lol
 
I have a Ford. I'm more of a 7-Up guy myself. But you make a valid point...
 
How come only gsgary is here, standing up for the twin-len reflex camera style???

143589784.jpg
 
How come only gsgary is here, standing up for the twin-len reflex camera style???

I was expecting CGW to jump in right about now.. I mean talk about a perfect lead in to the old DSLR is doomed.. doomed I say argument.. lol

Not to mention the unreliability of old cameras.
 
How come only gsgary is here, standing up for the twin-len reflex camera style???

143589784.jpg

Did i mention a tlr ? All i know is my Leicas will still going strong when all the dslr's are dead

Sent from my GT-I9100P using Tapatalk 2
 
Last edited:
There's always a "right tool for the job". Sometimes it could be a Leica S2, if you're in a studio. Do you want to take that S2 to a baseball diamond, hockey rink or a football or soccer field? Probably not.

Yeh because everyone knows it could rain in the studio.... that's why Leica engineers designed the S2 with weatherproofing and based their handling on existing DSLR designs that are tried and true in the field. Its also why they went through the trouble of using a dual shutter system and leaf shutter systems for high speed sync... its also part of the reason for a sensor size that falls inbetween FF and true MF... etc... etc.. etc.. etc...

er... :-/


But I do agree.... right tool for the job. I would even take it further...right tool for the right person. Everyone has different preferences. requirements, and needs.


Just please.... dont say that the S in S2 stands for "studio only". Its just as embarrassing as English/American members pointing out that Leica misspelled Monochrom.
 
Last edited:
Not to argue, but I just wonder how many of those S2s get used and abused in outdoor circumstances. I'm sure some are, but what percentage leave the studio would be interesting to know. From searching Leica rangefinders over and over and over on eBay, it seems like their products were generally used pretty well.
 
I know this is going to seem strange, but I, a member here, who knows how things seem to work, don't like arguments, but still come here. Yes, I come here and don't like arguing. For the most part, I've avoided it, but there have been two or three occasions. And for once, Robbins, my wife was already upstairs so I didn't get in trouble. :mrgreen: This time.
 
Not to argue, but I just wonder how many of those S2s get used and abused in outdoor circumstances. I'm sure some are, but what percentage leave the studio would be interesting to know. From searching Leica rangefinders over and over and over on eBay, it seems like their products were generally used pretty well.

No idea... but an easy google search just a minute ago and found this:

On the Mountain with the Leica S2 and Jonas Bendiksen | Hypebeast

"Leica, in partnership with Magnum Photos, presents an awe-inspiring look at the use of the Leica S2 camera during extreme conditions at Mont Blanc which sits at the base of the Alps"
 

Most reactions

New Topics

Back
Top Bottom